We have been part of the Crown Point community for nearly two centuries. From our humble beginnings in 1838, First United Methodist Church has grown alongside the town itself—adapting to change, welcoming new generations, and remaining rooted in faith.
Over the years, our congregation has worshiped in different buildings, embraced new ministries, and responded to the evolving needs of our neighbors. Through it all, our mission has remained the same: to share God’s love, serve with compassion, and build a welcoming space for all.
Take a trip through our personal history in Crown
The story of First United Methodist Church is one of faith, resilience, and community — a journey that began long before our walls were built.
Before 1838, services were held in humble log cabins, led by circuit riders who carried the Word of God across the countryside. In 1838, Isaac Stagg officially organized the church, marking the beginning of a legacy that would span nearly two centuries.
As Crown Point grew, so did the church. In 1887, twelve faithful families built the first church building on land donated by Solon Robinson and William Clark. Over the years, groups like the Ladies Aid Society and the Epworth League (now known as Amped) brought energy and purpose to the congregation, nurturing fellowship and service.
By the early 1900s, the church’s music ministry came to life — a pipe organ, purchased in 1910 with the help of Judge Elbert H. Gary, filled the sanctuary with music that still echoes in our hearts today.
Even through wars and hardship, the church stood united. In the 1940s and 1950s, churches across the community came together — sharing resources, praying for peace, and lifting one another in faith. The spirit of unity continued when the pipe organ was moved to a new church building in 1957, symbolizing both renewal and continuity.
The decades that followed revealed the church’s compassionate heart. In 1994, the congregation opened its doors to a refugee family from Bosnia, helping them find safety and a new beginning. In times of national sorrow, such as after the events of September 11 and the tragedy at Sandy Hook, our church responded with prayer, memorial, and love — reminding us that faith is not confined by walls, but defined by action.
Today, First United Methodist Church continues to be a place where faith, family, and community come together — a living testament to generations who believed, served, and built a foundation for all who would come after.